"Should I be an LLC or an S-Corp?" is probably the most-asked question in small-business taxes — and it's built on a misunderstanding. The two aren't competing options. One is a legal entity; the other is a tax status. Most owners who "choose the S-Corp" actually keep their LLC and simply change how it's taxed.
This guide untangles the comparison properly: what each one actually is, how the taxes differ, where the break-even sits, and how to decide for your income. If you want to skip to a number, our free S-Corp tax savings calculator estimates what the election would mean for you in about a minute.
1. The Thing Most Guides Get Wrong
An LLC (limited liability company) is a legal entity you form with your state. It exists to separate your business from you personally — if the business is sued or owes debts, your personal assets have a layer of protection. The LLC itself says nothing about how you're taxed.
An S-Corp is not an entity at all — it's a tax classification with the IRS. A qualifying LLC (or corporation) can elect it. So the real question is never "LLC or S-Corp?" It's: "Should my LLC keep its default taxation, or elect S-Corp taxation?" That's a question about your profit level, and it has a fairly clean answer.
You don't choose between an LLC and an S-Corp. You keep the LLC — and decide how it's taxed. The election changes your tax math, not your legal protection.
2. How a Default LLC Is Taxed
By default, a single-member LLC is taxed like a sole proprietorship: all net profit lands on your personal return, and essentially all of it is subject to self-employment tax — 15.3% (12.4% Social Security up to the annual wage base, around $184,500 for 2026, plus 2.9% Medicare with no cap) — on top of regular income tax.
The upside is simplicity. No payroll, no separate business tax return, minimal bookkeeping requirements. For a business earning modest profit, that simplicity is genuinely worth more than the tax savings an election would produce. If you're earlier in the journey, S-Corp basics explained covers the ground floor.
3. What the S-Corp Election Changes
An S-Corp splits your profit into two streams: a reasonable salary you pay yourself through payroll, and distributions you take as the owner. Payroll taxes apply to the salary — but not to the distributions. That gap is the engine of the savings.
The election also unlocks strategies that are awkward or impossible as a sole proprietor: a Solo 401(k) with an employer contribution calculated on your W-2 wages, an accountable plan for tax-free home-office and business-use reimbursements, and cleaner separation between you and the business. Stacked together, these are what turn the election from a nice-to-have into a meaningful annual number — the full breakdown lives in how much an S-Corp actually saves.
The price of admission is discipline. The salary must be reasonable for your role and market — artificially low salaries are a classic audit trigger — and you take on payroll, monthly books, and a separate business return. Setting that salary correctly is its own topic: see how to set a reasonable S-Corp salary.
How much would the election save you?
Our free calculator models the salary/distribution split — plus the layered strategies — for your income, state, and filing status. Estimate only; takes about a minute.
Calculate My Savings4. LLC vs S-Corp: The Side-by-Side
Here's the comparison that actually matters, dimension by dimension:
- Liability protection: identical. The LLC provides it either way — the election doesn't touch it.
- Self-employment tax: default LLC — on essentially all profit. S-Corp — only on your salary; distributions escape the 15.3%.
- Payroll: default LLC — none. S-Corp — required, for at least yourself, with quarterly filings and a W-2 each January.
- Tax filing: default LLC — one personal return (Schedule C). S-Corp — a separate business return (Form 1120-S) plus your personal return.
- Admin cost: default LLC — minimal. S-Corp — payroll, bookkeeping, and the business return, typically a few thousand dollars a year if you hire it out.
- Retirement leverage: S-Corp pulls ahead — the Solo 401(k) employer contribution rides on W-2 wages.
- Audit posture: both are fine when run cleanly; the S-Corp adds one sensitive variable — the reasonable-salary call — which is why documentation matters.
5. A Worked Example: $200,000 of Profit
Say you're a consultant with $200,000 of net profit and a defensible $80,000 reasonable salary. Rough numbers, framed as an estimate:
- Default LLC: self-employment tax applies to roughly $184,700 of net earnings — call it ≈ $28,200.
- With the S-Corp election: payroll tax applies only to the $80,000 salary — ≈ $12,200. The $120,000 taken as distributions isn't hit with the 15.3%.
- Estimated self-employment-tax savings: ≈ $16,000 a year — before layering the Solo 401(k), accountable plan, and the rest.
Two honest caveats. Part of these taxes is itself deductible, so the true net benefit runs a bit lower than the headline gap — our calculator accounts for that. And the figure scales with profit: at $150,000 with a $70,000 salary, the same mechanics produce an estimated high-four-figure to low-five-figure annual saving; at $400,000, meaningfully more. The point isn't the exact dollar amount — it's that the savings are structural and repeat every year you operate this way.
6. When to Stay Default — and When to Elect
Stay with default LLC taxation while net profit is below roughly $80,000–$100,000. Under that line, the added costs and obligations can swallow the savings, and simplicity wins. There's no prize for electing early — the election can wait until the math works.
Elect S-Corp status once profit clears that line and you expect it to stay there. The savings scale with profit, which is why owners in the $150,000+ range we focus on usually see the strongest net benefit — an estimated five figures a year for many, repeating every year the structure runs. The break-even arithmetic is laid out in what an S-Corp costs to set up and run.
One more clarification while we're here: if you've also seen "C-Corp" in your research, that's a different animal entirely — double taxation, built for reinvestment and outside investors. For an owner taking the profits home, that comparison is settled in S-Corp vs C-Corp.
7. Deadlines, Forms, and Paperwork
You don't dissolve anything or start over — your LLC stays exactly as it is, and what changes is its tax classification with the IRS. The election is requested on Form 2553, and timing matters: to take effect for a tax year, it's generally due no later than 2 months and 15 days after the start of that year (a brand-new LLC gets the same window measured from formation). Miss it, and the IRS offers late-election relief (Rev. Proc. 2013-30) when there's reasonable cause — a fix we prepare routinely.
Once the election is in effect, the operating rhythm changes: payroll comes online (with quarterly payroll filings and a W-2 for yourself each January), and the business files its own return — Form 1120-S, due March 15 each year, extendable to September. Keep the IRS's acceptance letter (Notice CP261) with your records; it's the proof your election is active.
Worth saying plainly: every form mentioned here is available free of charge at irs.gov. What we're paid for is preparing and filing them correctly as your authorized representative — with your written authorization — and running the payroll, books, and returns that follow. The full switch sequence lives in converting an LLC to an S-Corp.
8. State Wrinkles: California and Beyond
Federal savings are only part of the picture — states add their own quirks. The big one for our home state: California charges S-Corps a 1.5% franchise tax on net income, with an $800 annual minimum. That sounds discouraging until you run the numbers: for an owner above the break-even, the estimated federal self-employment-tax savings usually dwarf the 1.5% — but it belongs in the math, and our calculator's state input handles it.
Elsewhere: New York requires its own separate state S election on top of the federal one, New York City's general corporation tax famously doesn't recognize the S election at all, and a handful of states layer entity-level taxes or fees on S-Corps. None of these usually kill the math — but they're exactly the kind of detail that separates a clean setup from an expensive surprise, and they're part of what we check before recommending the election in your state.
9. Five Mistakes That Burn New S-Corps
- Electing too early. Below the income break-even, the costs eat the savings — the election should wait for the profit, not the other way around.
- Paying an indefensibly low salary. The single most common trigger for scrutiny. "Reasonable" means defensible against your role, hours, and market data.
- Skipping payroll entirely in year one. An S-Corp owner who takes only distributions and no W-2 wages is a textbook red flag.
- Letting the books lag all year. Distributions, basis, and reimbursements need clean records — reconstructing them at tax time costs more than keeping them.
- Assuming the election is active without confirmation. Until the IRS acceptance letter (CP261) arrives, don't file as an S-Corp on hope.
Every one of these is avoidable with the structure run properly — which is exactly the job we do end to end: setup, payroll, bookkeeping, and the returns, handled as your authorized representative.
10. See What the Election Would Mean for You
The general rules only narrow it down — the real answer depends on your profit, your state, your filing status, and a defensible salary for your work. Our S-Corp tax savings calculator takes those inputs and estimates your annual savings, including the layered strategies. From there, a short call with an Enrolled Agent turns the estimate into a decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an S-Corp better than an LLC for taxes?
Often, once your profit is high enough — but it's the wrong comparison. An LLC is a legal entity; S-Corp is a tax status your LLC can elect. By default, all of an LLC's profit is subject to self-employment tax. With the election, payroll tax applies only to your reasonable salary, not the distributions on top of it. Once profit clears roughly $80,000–$100,000, that gap usually outruns the added costs. Your actual result depends on your profit, salary, and state.
Can an LLC be taxed as an S-Corp?
Yes. You keep the LLC as your legal entity and elect S-Corp tax treatment with the IRS. Your liability protection doesn't change — what changes is how the IRS taxes the profit: a reasonable salary through payroll, with profit above it available as distributions that aren't subject to self-employment tax.
At what income should an LLC elect S-Corp status?
A common rule of thumb is around $80,000–$100,000 of net profit. Below that, payroll, bookkeeping, and the separate business return can eat up the savings. Owners earning $150,000 and up typically see the largest net benefit, with estimated savings that repeat every year the structure runs.
What are the downsides of electing S-Corp status?
Real obligations: running payroll for yourself, keeping clean monthly books, filing a separate business return (Form 1120-S), and paying yourself a defensible reasonable salary. Handled poorly, these create audit risk; handled well, they typically cost a few thousand dollars a year — which is why the election only makes sense above the income break-even.
Do I need to form a corporation to get S-Corp taxation?
No. Most owners keep an LLC and simply elect S-Corp tax treatment. A state-law corporation can also elect S-Corp status, but for a typical owner-operated business the LLC-plus-election route preserves the LLC's flexibility while capturing the tax benefits.
When is the deadline to elect S-Corp status?
For an existing business, Form 2553 is generally due no later than 2 months and 15 days after the start of the tax year you want the election to cover; a new LLC has the same window measured from formation. If the window is missed, the IRS allows late-election relief with reasonable cause — a routine fix when handled properly.
Does California charge S-Corps a tax?
Yes — California levies a 1.5% franchise tax on an S-Corp's net income, with an $800 annual minimum. For owners above the income break-even, the estimated federal self-employment-tax savings usually far exceed the 1.5%, but it belongs in your math, which is why our calculator includes a state input.
LLC Today — Wondering If the Election Pays?
Estimate your savings in about a minute with our free calculator, then book a free consultation with an Enrolled Agent. If the math works, we handle the election, payroll, books, and returns — all in.
Schedule a Free Consultation